Editorial Illustration: University of Michigan football coach Kyle Whittingham navigates a sea of Zingerman’s Roadhouse butterscotch pudding inside Michigan Stadium on his 67th birthday alongside a $25 million buyout contract, a December 1 calendar marking the arrival of incoming University President C. Cybele Raver and Athletic Director Trev Alberts, and a nod to Raver’s television-surgeon sister, Kim Raver. (Illustration by The St. Croix Sun / Nano Banana 2)
By: JOHN McCARTHY / St. Croix Sun Sports Reporter
ANN ARBOR, Mich. — There is an old German philosophical concept popularized by Friedrich Nietzsche called eternal recurrence—the terrifying hypothesis that you are condemned to live the exact same life, complete with every agonizing humiliation and baffling plot twist, over and over again for all eternity.
Nietzsche never attended a November afternoon at Michigan Stadium, though if he had watched the Wolverines manage six points against Michigan State before getting run out of Eugene 31-7 by Oregon, he would have nodded knowingly and ordered a stiff drink.
Three short years ago, Michigan football stood atop the college sports world as undefeated national champions under Jim Harbaugh. Today, the program resembles less a blue-blood athletic powerhouse and more a medical-drama crossover written by Samuel Beckett and directed by the Washtenaw County Prosecutor’s Office.
Appropriately enough, the woman tapped to stop the bleeding on campus has family ties to prime-time triage. Incoming University of Michigan President C. Cybele Raver happens to be the sister of television actress Kim Raver, best known for playing cardiothoracic surgeon Dr. Teddy Altman on Grey’s Anatomy. One can only hope some of that fictional operating-room poise runs in the family, because Michigan’s athletic department is currently in critical condition.
Consider the sheer velocity of the off-field circus in Ann Arbor since the confetti fell in Houston:
Hamburger-gate: NCAA investigators descending on campus over a couple of cheeseburgers bought for recruits during a dead period.
Signal-Stealing-gate: A rogue staffer armed with a sideline manifesto, sunglasses, and an iPhone turning Big Ten scouting into an espionage thriller.
The Federal Hacking Scandal: Former co-offensive coordinator Matt Weiss indicted by federal prosecutors for allegedly breaching student-athletes’ private online accounts.
Sherrone-Moore-gate: Harbaugh’s hand-picked successor fired for cause last December over an inappropriate relationship with a staffer, arrested hours later, and eventually sentenced to probation.
DoorDash-gate: Just this week, wide receiver Andrew Marsh hit with a misdemeanor indecent exposure charge stemming from a February food delivery—proving that at Michigan, even ordering takeout carries the risk of a court date.
To restore order after the Moore implosion, outgoing Athletic Director Warde Manuel handed a five-year, $41 million contract to longtime Utah coach Kyle Whittingham. Whittingham, who celebrates his 67th birthday today as his 5-5 Wolverines host No. 4 UCLA at the Big House, was supposed to be the no-nonsense adult in the room. Instead, Michigan has rotated quarterbacks like a minor-league baseball team, and Whittingham has reportedly clashed with stakeholders who feel he has resisted embracing "Michigan culture." (Given what Michigan culture has produced in the police blotter lately, one can hardly blame him for keeping a safe distance.)
Even in modern college football, nobody is cruel enough to fire a coach on his 67th birthday before kickoff—especially when the corporate chain of command is stuck in a bureaucratic twilight zone.
C. Cybele Raver—who does not officially take office until December 1—convened the Board of Regents this week to hire Texas A&M Athletic Director Trev Alberts to replace the departing Manuel. Alberts, a former Nebraska linebacker who treats buyouts like Monopoly money, also does not officially start until December 1. That leaves a glorious ten-day purgatory in which a lame-duck athletic director oversees a dead-man-walking football coach while the incoming president and incoming athletic director wait in the lobby with a $25 million severance check.
Naturally, desperate Wolverines fans have already begun hallucinating a rescue mission. When CBS Sports floated Indiana head coach Curt Cignetti as a potential target, Cignetti replied on social media with a clown emoji and dismissed the report as "fake news." Of course, college football fans have heard that song before. Nick Saban famously declared he would not be the coach at Alabama right up until the moment he boarded a plane to Tuscaloosa. Still, prying Cignetti away from a 9-1 defending national champion powerhouse—where he has lost just three games in three seasons (36-3) and makes $13.2 million a year through 2033—would require a fortune so vast that even Elon Musk might pause before writing the check—at least until he finally packs his bags and relocates SpaceX to St. Croix.
Which brings suffering alumni back to the only reliable institution left in Washtenaw County: the dessert menu at Zingerman’s Roadhouse. As longtime Michigan sports host Dennis Fithian recently observed, when the offense cannot find the end zone and the athletic department is stuck in an administrative traffic jam, a warm bowl of Roadhouse butterscotch pudding is the lone bright spot in Ann Arbor.
Can the Michigan phoenix rise from the ashes of discontent once again? History says yes. Eventually, the buyouts clear, the new administrators take their seats, and a fresh savior steps to the podium. Until then, light the birthday candles and pass the spoon.